A DeFi-native research hub curating a collection of high-quality research pieces from the most skilled and respected creators in the space


New Wave of NFT Finance:

We’ve all been told that bear markets are for builders, but what does that mean for the NFT sector? Get to work drawing more birds, bears, and apes? On the contrary, plenty of NFT-centric DeFi protocols have emerged recently and expanded the utility available to JPEG holders – and plenty of new contenders are entering the playing field.

Frogs has covered this crossover between DeFi and NFTs previously, and Leveraged Degen did a terrific job outlining early movers in the space like SudoSwap,, and NFTfi. These were projects that centered around increasing liquidity for NFTs. They introduced gasless swaps, NFT collateralized loans, and an aggregated marketplace. Now a new wave of NFT DeFi is on the rise, with a new set of ambitions. These projects want to introduce things like NFT appraisal markets and NFT derivatives.

So who are they? Let’s take a look at two protocols that are getting ready to step in and change the game. Today, we'll start with Abacus. Appraisals for NFTs

It’s been said a million times before, but I’ll say it again: liquidity is king. In this case, it's the king of providing valuations for illiquid assets, and you can see how that process might be difficult. To put it simply, no individual knows the true price of a cigarette smoking monkey in a pirate hat. If you have one and want to find out, your only choice is to list it for a price you hope someone else will accept, or leave it up to chance in an auction. Of course, there’s a floor price and prior sales to give some guidance, but in essence it's worth what someone else will pay for it. Is there a better way to get an accurate estimate?

NFTs Reimagined

NFTs Reimagined is on a mission to introduce liquidity-backed appraisals to the NFT space, cooking up a slightly complex but well thought out mechanism for doing so. The basic gist is this: the owner of an NFT lists it on Abacus looking for liquid backing and appraisers provide it based on their belief of what the NFT would sell for at auction. In the process, they essentially crowdsource a proper valuation for the NFT.

Sounds simple enough. So how does it work?

Protocol Mechanics

Source: Abacus

Source: Abacus

  1. A “spot pool” can be created by anyone with tranches that appraisers can fill with ETH.
  • You can think of a spot pool as a vault for the NFTs and liquidity.
  • For example, Pool A is created, and can hold up to 3 CryptoPunks with up to 225 tranches.

  2. The owner of the corresponding NFT(s) signs the pool in order to activate it and turn on rewards for appraisers while retaining custody of their NFTs, and appraisers deposit ETH to fill tranches.

  • They are essentially buying a tranche of the NFT that they believe will be lower or equal to its value at auction.
  • Ex: 3 punks are deposited and Pool A is signed by the Punks owner. Appraiser A fills the 0-1 ETH tranche, meaning he believes the Punk 1 is worth more than 1 ETH at auction

  3. NFT depositor(s) have the option to close their position, exchanging their JPEG for their share of the ETH in the pool.

  • Ex: Pool A is now 100% full and the Punks owners closes their first position in it, exchanging Punk 1 for 75 (225 tranches / 3 NFTs) tranches, worth a total of 75 ETH

  4. Once a position is closed, the underlying NFT goes up for auction and tranche holders are paid out on a first in first out basis.

  • Ex: Punk 1 closes and the NFT sells for 100 ETH, the 75 appraisers who filled those tranches each receive 1.33 ETH. Alternatively if the NFT sells for less than the appraised value, say 50 ETH, appraisers filling tranches 0-50 are paid out and those occupying the 50-75 tranches receive nothing.


This is the basic mechanism of Abacus: appraisers are incentivized to give realistic valuations as they will only be paid out if sale price is above the tranche level they bought into. NFT owners are incentivized to participate in pools to receive liquid backing for their JPEGs, which they can access by closing the pool, or take into the wider NFT x DeFi ecosystem to obtain loans on their NFT.

This system is great for NFT owners, but what about the appraisers? Why should they potentially risk their ETH backing NFTs? This is where Abacus’ native token comes into play.


Abacus’ ABC token is used for revenue sharing, ve-style gauge control, and governance purposes. Revenues are distributed proportionally among ABC holders who participate in an epoch’s gauge allocation, which involves voting for certain collections to offer boosted rewards to appraisers. These incentives attract appraisers, giving them influence over protocol governance and sharing revenue to balance the risk of backing an NFT.

Sources of Revenue

Sources of Revenue

Revenues are generated through four avenues within the protocol:

  • Closure fees: a 1% fee on the liquidity an NFT depositor receives by closing their position
  • Priority closure purchases: NFT depositors can purchase rights to close their position before others in the same pool, ensuring available liquidity
  • Improper appraisals: when slashed appraisals > auction price for closed NFT the difference becomes protocol revenue
  • Epoch Distribution Credits purchases (EDC)

EDC are essentially a claim on ABC, used to determine the proportion of an epoch’s emissions each appraiser will receive. EDC are acquired after an NFT position is closed, costing the appraiser a fee of 1% of the liquidity they provided.

Generally speaking, the more liquidity they back, the more EDC are available to them. Appraiser rewards also depend on tranche position, as higher tranches will see their rewards boosted to compensate for the added risk, while lower, safer, tranche rewards are reduced. Gauge allocation also plays a role, as pools containing boosted collections will net their appraisers extra rewards too.

All active pools generate an amount of EDC rewards equal to the amount of ETH in the pool, with a cap at 100 EDC. The 2 million in ABC emissions are then paid out proportionally to each appraiser’s share of the total EDC for all pools. Ex. Appraiser A earns 10 EDC in epoch 1, with a total EDC amount of 1000 across all pools. Appraiser A would receive 1% of the 2 million ABC emission, 20,000 ABC.

Summing Up Abacus

Believe me, I had to read the whitepaper about six times over to get a solid grasp on Abacus, as it truly is an innovative and ambitious project. I do think some things can be streamlined, like getting rid of EDCs, which seem like an extra step in the rewards claiming process. Then there’s additional features like credit bonds and different types of bribes that I didn’t include here for brevity’s sake. Either way, reliable valuations and liquid backing are exactly what NFTs need to further unlock their potential as assets, and Abacus provides both. There’s a reason tons of other NFT protocols, and even Redacted Cartel are partnering with Abacus. Will it become the Curve of the NFT world?

I would highly recommend reading the Abacus whitepaper to get a deeper understanding of the protocol.

Tomorrow we'll be back with an equally exciting project: NFTperp. NFTperp will offer perpetual futures on NFTs, allowing users to long, short, and hedge exposure to their own collections, along with many more features. So tune in then, because this will be a good one.

Published on Aug 23 2022

Written By:




Copyright © 2022 NEW ORDER. All Rights Reserved

Privacy PolicyToken Terms and Conditions